The Best Places To Buy Natural Fancy Color Diamonds Online

fancy color diamonds


On this page I list those companies that are jewelers that provide the full online shopping service. To be included on this list the jeweler had to not only have a good product, but had to make their product easily searchable and accessible. I also figured that most people searching for the best place to buy fancy color diamonds online would be looking for more than merely an amped up business card. These websites are complete online shops. They also offer good terms and excellent customer service.

When searching for diamonds online you will find that there are hundreds if not thousands of online diamond jewelers that list a huge number of diamonds but don’t include a great deal of information.

Therefore, to be included on this list there are several criteria which had to be fulfilled.

  1. The jeweler is experienced at transacting online and running an efficient website.
  2. There are photos of the actual diamonds, not only stock sample photos.
  3. The diamond’s lab report, also known as diamond grading certificate, is listed along with the diamond.
  4. The return/inspection period is more than 7 days.
  5. The jeweler must be part of the Kimberly process to ensure the diamonds are conflict free.
  6. They must have a proven track record of outstanding customer service.
  7. I gladly recommend any of these to my closest friends.

Asteria Diamonds


Natural color diamonds and custom jewelry
Natural color diamonds and custom jewelry

Asteria Diamonds has been in the diamond trade since 1973. They are mostly known as a supplier of high quality jewelry and natural colored diamonds to the jewelry trade . (read their story here) Asteria Diamonds is a diamond and jewelry manufacturing firm. This means they both source their diamonds from mines and are responsible for the cutting, polishing, grading. They also handle the eventual sale. In 2012 they launched their online store offering a dazzling array of color diamonds as well as diamond jewelry directly to a global audience. The website boasts a wonderful inventory spanning different sizes, cuts, qualities and colors of fancy diamonds. The quality of the jewelry Asteria Diamonds offers shows the pride they take in their work. It’s quite clear that they take special care to provide pieces that will be treasured by their customers. Asteria Diamonds has their headquarters in Israel with offices across the globe from New York to London. Asteria diamonds stands out among other online diamond jewelers as they are one of a few online diamond jewelers that own their stock. This means you can arrange an inspection if you so desire at one of their offices. They also have a very generous lifetime upgrade guarantee. Another service they offer is custom jewelry. You can send them a sketch or a photo of the ring you want and Asteria Diamonds’ in house jeweler will design and make it.

Fancy Intense Yellow Diamond Ring From Asteria Diamonds

Leibish & Co: Fancy Color Diamonds


Leibish & Co: Fancy Color Diamonds and Jewelry
Leibish & Co: Fancy Color Diamonds and Jewelry

Leibish & Co. is an internationally recognized specialist in natural fancy colored diamonds and colored diamond jewelry. The close-knit family business of father, daughter, and four sons began in 1979 and today is a major supplier to renowned jewelers, designers, and manufacturers around the world.

Leibish & Co. offers one of the largest online selections of color diamonds with both fancy and ideal cuts in various hues, clarities and sizes set for any budget, with a focus on Argyle Pink and Canary Yellow diamonds. Stones are mined in Australia, Africa, India, and Russia. As with all the jewelers I list on all diamonds come from legitimate, conflict-free sources complying with UN Resolutions.

Leibish & Co. was one of the very first fancy color diamond companies to go online, and as such have a clear understanding as to how to provide top quality and useful detailed information to their customers through their website. Founder Leibish Polnauer recognized early the Internet’s potential as a sales, marketing, and service channel to reach customers worldwide. At the start of the 21st Century Leibish & Co also began manufacturing their own jewelry designs. Using color diamonds precisely calibrated for size, and graded for color Leibish & Co’s color diamond engagement rings are the company’s best sellers, although they create a wide range of jewelry from general items through to haute couture fine jewelry pieces. All Leibish & Co. diamonds and jewelry come certified with a GIA, Argyle, IGI, or in-house diamond certificates.

The Leibish & Co. website features a comprehensive knowledge center for the fancy color diamond industry, including informative articles and investment materials, and also offers a direct purchasing channel for global buyers.

  • 30 day Returns
  • Free Shipping
  • Outstanding Customer Service
    • Answers Emails
    • Returns your phone calls
    • Knowledgeable and extremely helpful consultants
    • One-on-one relationship between clients and company employees
  • Gives you access to pink Argyle diamonds

Click on any of the above images to find that color at


Also highly recommended:


A beautiful Fancy Light Yellow Diamond Ring from